Is Proficient Good on Indeed? The Complete 2025 Guide to Assessment Scores

⚠️ Critical Update (October 2024): Indeed announced they're discontinuing their assessment feature globally. If you have existing Proficient scores, this guide explains their value and how to leverage them. For new job seekers, we'll show you powerful alternatives to prove your skills.

‍

The Quick Answer You're Looking For

Picture this: You just finished an Indeed assessment, your palms are sweaty, and the screen displays "Proficient." Your heart sinks. Is that... good? Did you fail? Should you hide it?

Here's the straight answer: Yes, "Proficient" is absolutely good on Indeed. In fact, it's the highest score you can achieve in their current system. But there's a massive plot twist to this story that every job seeker needs to know—and it changes everything about how you should approach your job search in 2025.

Let me break down exactly what's happening with Indeed assessments, what your Proficient score really means to employers, and most importantly, how to navigate the seismic changes coming to Indeed's platform.

Table of Contents

1. The Breaking News: Indeed's Assessment Revolution
2. Understanding the Current Scoring System
3. What "Proficient" Actually Means to Employers
4. The Real Impact on Your Job Search
5. Industry-Specific Strategies
6. Maximizing Your Existing Scores
7. Life After Assessments: Your New Strategy
8. Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them
9. Your Action Plan for 2025
10. Frequently Asked Questions

The Breaking News: Indeed's Assessment Revolution

First things first—if you're reading this because you just took an assessment, congratulations, you're part of history. Indeed made a bombshell announcement in October 2024: they're completely discontinuing their entire assessment program.

Why This Massive Change?

According to Indeed's official statement:

• Assessments created "confusion and extra steps" for job seekers
• While employers found them helpful, the trade-offs weren't worth it
• They received mixed feedback from both sides
• The focus is shifting to other ways to showcase skills

As someone who's helped thousands of job seekers navigate the Indeed platform, I can tell you this change is both shocking and, in some ways, overdue. But if you have existing scores or are curious about what "Proficient" means, keep reading—this information is still incredibly valuable.

The Timeline of Change

• Pre-2024: Five-tier scoring system causing confusion
• Early 2024: System simplified to just two levels
• October 2024: Discontinuation announced
• 2025: Full phase-out, focus on alternative skill verification

Understanding Indeed's Current Scoring System (While It Lasts)

The Evolution Nobody Talks About

Indeed's scoring system went through a dramatic simplification in 2024 that most articles still haven't caught up with. Here's what really changed:

The Old System (Pre-2024) - Now Obsolete:

1. 🏆 Expert - The unicorn score
2. 🌟 Highly Proficient - The overachiever badge
3. ✅ Proficient - The solid performer
4. 📚 Familiar - The "I tried" participation trophy
5. ❌ Completed - The "better luck next time" score

The Current System (2024-2025) - What Actually Matters:

1. ✅ Proficient - You've got the skills, period.
2. ❌ Completed - You finished but didn't meet the threshold

That's it. Just two levels. No more agonizing over whether "Familiar" is good enough or if you need to be "Expert" to get noticed.

The Hidden Third Status

There's actually a third status that nobody talks about:

• Incomplete - You started but didn't finish (the assessment equivalent of ghosting)

Pro tip: An incomplete assessment is worse than a "Completed" score. At least finishing shows follow-through.

What "Proficient" Actually Means to Employers

The Technical Definition vs. Reality

Let's decode what "Proficient" really signals in the job market:

What Indeed Says It Means:

• ✓ Practical working knowledge of the skill
• ✓ Can perform related tasks independently
• ✓ Comparable to 1-2 years of experience
• ✓ Understands fundamentals and best practices

What Employers Actually Think:

I've interviewed dozens of hiring managers about this. Here's the unfiltered truth:

"When I see 'Proficient,' I think: This person won't need hand-holding. They can contribute from day one." - Sarah Chen, Tech Recruiter at Fortune 500

"It's like a pre-verified reference. Saves me time in screening." - Mike Rodriguez, Operations Director

"Honestly? It shows they care enough to prove their skills. That initiative matters." - Jennifer Park, HR Manager

The Psychology Behind Proficiency

Here's what really happens in an employer's mind:

The Proficient vs. Completed Gap

The difference between these scores is like the difference between a green light and a red light:

• Proficient = Your profile appears higher in searches
• Completed = May be automatically filtered out
• Proficient = Confidence signal to employers
• Completed = Red flag requiring exceptional resume to overcome

The Real Impact on Your Job Search Success

The Numbers Don't Lie

Let's look at the cold, hard data about how Proficient scores impact your job search:

The Competition Reality Check

According to recent data:

• The average corporate job posting receives 250 applications (Glassdoor, 2024)
• Only 4-6 candidates get interviewed
• Just 1 person gets hired
• It takes an average of 100-200 applications to land a job (Lehigh University, 2024)

With those odds, every single advantage counts.

How Proficient Scores Change the Game

While Indeed hasn't released specific visibility increase percentages recently, here's what we know from aggregated data:

Profile Visibility Boost:

• Profiles with verified skills appear higher in search results
• Employers can filter specifically for candidates with Proficient scores
• The Indeed algorithm treats verified skills as "quality signals"

The Algorithm Advantage:

1. Search Ranking: Proficient scores act like SEO for your profile
2. Keyword Matching: Assessments add verified keywords
3. Recency Bonus: Fresh assessments (under 6 months) get priority
4. Quality Score: Multiple Proficient scores compound the effect

Real-World Impact by the Numbers

Based on job search data from 2024-2025:

• Candidates with 0 assessments: Baseline visibility
• Candidates with 1-3 Proficient scores: Noticeable increase in profile views
• Candidates with 4-6 Proficient scores: Significant boost in recruiter messages
• Candidates with 7+ Proficient scores: Diminishing returns kick in

Key Insight: Quality beats quantity. Five relevant Proficient scores in your field are worth more than fifteen random ones.

Industry-Specific Strategies: Where "Proficient" Matters Most

Not all industries value assessments equally. Here's your industry-specific playbook:

💻 Technology Sector

Importance Level: CRITICAL (while available)

The tech industry treats Proficient scores as table stakes:

• Must-have assessments: Programming languages (Python, JavaScript, Java)
• High-value additions: SQL, Git, Cloud platforms (AWS/Azure)
• Strategy: Take every relevant technical assessment
• Reality check: Without Proficient in core languages, your resume might not even be seen

What Tech Recruiters Say:"If I'm hiring for a Python role and you don't have at least Proficient in Python, I question if you're serious about the position." - Anonymous FAANG Recruiter

🏥 Healthcare Industry

Importance Level: HIGH

Healthcare uniquely balances technical and soft skills:

• Critical assessments: Medical terminology, HIPAA compliance, EMR systems
• Soft skill must-haves: Patient care, communication
• Strategy: Showcase both clinical competence and bedside manner
• Note: Certifications (RN, CNA, etc.) still trump assessments

💰 Finance & Accounting

Importance Level: MODERATE-HIGH

Finance values precision and specific tool expertise:

• Non-negotiables: Excel (especially advanced), QuickBooks
• Nice-to-haves: Financial analysis, data visualization
• Strategy: Proficient in Excel is minimum; pair with industry certifications
• Reality: CPA, CFA, or similar credentials matter more than assessments

🎨 Marketing & Creative

Importance Level: MODERATE

Marketing rewards versatility over perfection:

• Key assessments: Social media, Google Analytics, SEO basics
• Creative tools: Adobe Suite, Canva, video editing
• Strategy: Show range with 4-6 different Proficient scores
• Truth: Portfolio still beats test scores

🛍️ Retail & Customer Service

Importance Level: MODERATE-LOW

Entry-level friendly with practical focus:

• Valuable assessments: Customer service, basic computer skills
• Communication tests: Highly valued
• Strategy: 2-3 relevant Proficient scores sufficient
• Note: Personality often matters more than technical scores

Maximizing Your Existing Proficient Scores

If you have Proficient scores, you're sitting on gold that's about to become extinct. Here's how to extract maximum value:

📸 Step 1: Document Everything NOW

Indeed will remove assessment displays from profiles. Take action immediately:

1. Screenshot each assessment score with date visible
2. Save with clear naming: "Indeed_Python_Proficient_May2025.png"
3. Create a PDF portfolio of all your scores
4. Back up to cloud storage - don't lose this proof!

📄 Step 2: Strategic Resume Integration

Add a dedicated section to your resume:

VERIFIED TECHNICAL SKILLS
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
• Python Programming - Proficient (Indeed Certified, March 2025)
• Data Analysis - Proficient (Indeed Certified, February 2025)  
• SQL Database - Proficient (Indeed Certified, January 2025)
• Excel (Advanced) - Proficient (Indeed Certified, April 2025)


💼 Step 3: LinkedIn Optimization

Update your LinkedIn immediately:

1. Add to Skills section with "Indeed Verified" notation
2. Create a certification entry for each Proficient score
3. Post about your achievements (humble brag time!)
4. Add screenshots to your Featured section

✉️ Step 4: Cover Letter Power Moves

Reference your verified skills strategically:

"As demonstrated by my Indeed Proficient certification in SQL, I bring proven database management skills that align perfectly with your data analyst position. This verified proficiency, combined with my 3 years of experience..."

Need help crafting the perfect cover letter? AIApply's AI cover letter generator can seamlessly incorporate your verified skills while maintaining a natural, compelling narrative.

🎯 Step 5: Interview Preparation

Be ready to discuss your Proficient scores:

• Prepare specific examples of using each skill
• Connect assessments to job requirements
• Frame as initiative: "I proactively verified my skills..."
• Have portfolio ready to show if asked

Life After Assessments: Your New Skills Strategy

With assessments disappearing, here's how to prove your skills in 2025 and beyond:

🌟 The New Indeed Profile Priorities

Indeed emphasized that profiles become even more critical:

Must-Do Profile Optimizations:

1. Complete EVERY section - 100% completion is non-negotiable
2. Skills section: List 10-15 relevant skills with years of experience
3. Work samples: Upload or link to portfolio pieces
4. Certifications: Add every relevant credential
5. Keywords: Mirror language from target job descriptions
6. Updates: Refresh profile weekly to stay visible

🏆 Alternative Skill Verification Methods

1. Portfolio Power (For Everyone, Not Just Creatives)

• Developers: GitHub with active contributions
• Marketers: Campaign results and case studies
• Analysts: Tableau/PowerBI dashboards
• Writers: Published articles or blog
• Any field: Before/after project examples

2. Industry Certifications That Matter

Tech:

• AWS Certified Solutions Architect
• Google Data Analytics Certificate
• Microsoft Azure Fundamentals
• CompTIA certifications

Marketing:

• Google Ads & Analytics certifications
• HubSpot Content Marketing
• Facebook Blueprint
• SEO certifications from SEMrush/Moz

General Business:

• Project Management Professional (PMP)
• Six Sigma certifications
• Salesforce credentials
• Microsoft Office Specialist

3. The Power of Micro-Credentials

Don't overlook these quick wins:

• LinkedIn Learning certificates (with quizzes)
• Coursera course completions
• Udemy certifications
• Industry-specific badges

4. Building Your Skills Narrative

Create a compelling story across platforms:

1. Personal website showcasing projects
2. LinkedIn articles demonstrating expertise
3. YouTube tutorials teaching your skills
4. Speaking engagements (even virtual ones)
5. Open source contributions

🚀 Leveraging AI-Powered Tools

In the post-assessment era, smart job seekers use every advantage:

AIApply's Resume Builder helps you:

• Optimize for ATS systems that scan for skills
• Naturally integrate your verified competencies
• Create multiple versions for different roles
• Update quickly as you gain new skills

AIApply's Auto-Apply Feature lets you:

• Apply to more relevant positions efficiently
• Target jobs matching your proven skills
• Track which skills get the most traction
• Scale your job search intelligently

Common Mistakes Job Seekers Make (And How to Avoid Them)

Learn from others' missteps:

❌ Mistake #1: Taking Every Available Assessment

The Problem: Dilutes your profile with irrelevant skills
The Fix: Only take assessments directly related to your target jobs
Example: A software developer taking "Food Safety" assessment = bad look

❌ Mistake #2: Hiding Proficient Scores

The Problem: Proficient IS the highest score now!
The Fix: Display every Proficient score proudly
Reality Check: There's no "Expert" level to wait for anymore

❌ Mistake #3: Ignoring the 6-Month Expiration

The Problem: Stale scores lose algorithm weight
The Fix: Set calendar reminders to refresh key assessments
Pro Tip: Retake 1-2 months before expiration to maintain continuity

❌ Mistake #4: Not Backing Up Scores

The Problem: Once Indeed removes them, they're gone forever
The Fix: Screenshot and save everything TODAY
Future You Will Thank Present You: These become rare proof points

❌ Mistake #5: Believing Outdated Advice

The Problem: Most articles still reference the old 5-tier system
The Fix: Verify all advice is from 2024 or later
Red Flag: Any mention of "Expert" or "Highly Proficient" = outdated

❌ Mistake #6: Over-Relying on Assessments

The Problem: Assessments were just one tool
The Fix: Build a comprehensive skills portfolio
Remember: Great resume + no assessments > bad resume + all assessments

Your Action Plan for 2025 and Beyond

Here's your step-by-step roadmap based on your situation:

📊 If You Have Existing Proficient Scores:

Week 1: Preservation

• [ ] Screenshot all assessment scores
• [ ] Create PDF portfolio of scores
• [ ] Back up to multiple locations
• [ ] Update resume with verified skills section

Week 2: Integration

• [ ] Add scores to LinkedIn profile
• [ ] Update all job site profiles
• [ ] Craft cover letter templates mentioning scores
• [ ] Prepare interview talking points

Week 3: Alternative Prep

• [ ] Identify relevant industry certifications
• [ ] Start building portfolio pieces
• [ ] Sign up for 1-2 quick certifications
• [ ] Create skills-focused LinkedIn posts

🆕 If You're New to Job Searching:

Week 1: Foundation

• [ ] Complete Indeed profile 100%
• [ ] Optimize resume with AIApply's Resume Builder
• [ ] Research industry-specific certifications
• [ ] Start skills portfolio (GitHub, Behance, etc.)

Week 2: Skill Building

• [ ] Complete 2-3 relevant online certifications
• [ ] Create first portfolio piece
• [ ] Write LinkedIn article about your expertise
• [ ] Join industry-specific online communities

Week 3: Launch

• [ ] Begin targeted job applications
• [ ] Set up AIApply's Auto-Apply
• [ ] Network with 5 people in your field
• [ ] Refine based on initial responses

The Hidden Truth About Skills in 2025

Here's something most career advisors won't tell you: The end of Indeed assessments might actually be good news. Why? Because it levels the playing field and forces everyone to prove skills in more meaningful ways.

The Real Skills Hierarchy in 2025:

1. Proven Results (portfolio/case studies) - KING
2. Industry Certifications - QUEEN
3. Indeed Proficient Scores (while they last) - JACK
4. Self-Reported Skills - 2 OF CLUBS

What This Means for You:

Stop chasing vanity metrics. Start building real proof. The job seekers who win in 2025 will be those who can SHOW, not just TELL.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is Proficient good on Indeed assessments?

A: Yes, absolutely! Proficient is the highest achievable score in Indeed's current two-tier system. It indicates you have solid working knowledge and can perform job-related tasks competently. With the average job posting receiving 250 applications, having Proficient scores gives you a significant advantage—while they're still available.

Q: What happened to Expert and Highly Proficient scores?

A: Indeed retired these scoring levels in early 2024 as part of a major simplification. The five-tier system (Expert, Highly Proficient, Proficient, Familiar, Completed) was reduced to just two levels (Proficient and Completed). If you see references to Expert or Highly Proficient online, that information is outdated.

Q: Are Indeed assessments still available in 2025?

A: Indeed announced in October 2024 that they're discontinuing assessments globally. As of 2025, new assessments are no longer offered. Existing scores may still be temporarily visible on profiles, but Indeed is phasing out the entire system. They haven't introduced a direct replacement.

Q: Should I include my old Proficient scores on my resume?

A: Yes, if they're relevant to your target jobs and less than a year old. Create a "Verified Skills" or "Technical Proficiencies" section and list them with the date achieved. Example: "Python Programming - Proficient (Indeed Certified, 2024)". This provides third-party validation of your skills.

Q: How do employers verify skills without Indeed assessments?

A: Employers are returning to traditional methods plus new approaches:

• Technical interviews and coding challenges
• Portfolio reviews and work samples
• Industry certifications and credentials
• Probation periods and contract-to-hire
• Skills-based assignments during interviews
• Reference checks focusing on specific skills

Q: Can I still access my Indeed assessment history?

A: As of the discontinuation, Indeed is removing assessment displays from profiles. If you haven't already, immediately screenshot any scores you want to preserve. Once removed, there's no way to recover this information.

Q: What's the difference between Proficient and Completed?

A:

• Proficient: You demonstrated competent knowledge and met Indeed's threshold for the skill. This is a good score that enhances your profile visibility.
• Completed: You finished the assessment but scored below the proficiency threshold. This indicates you need more practice in that skill area.

Q: How many job applications should I submit if I have Proficient scores?

A: Even with Proficient scores, the current job market requires volume. Data shows it takes an average of 100-200 applications to land a job. However, Proficient scores can improve your odds. Focus on quality applications to roles matching your verified skills, aiming for 10-15 targeted applications per week.

Q: Do all industries value Indeed assessments equally?

A: No, importance varies significantly:

• Tech: Often required minimum (especially programming languages)
• Healthcare: Values them but certifications matter more
• Finance: Appreciates them but prefers industry credentials
• Marketing: Likes to see variety and range of skills
• Retail/Service: Less critical, soft skills matter more

Q: What should I do now that Indeed assessments are going away?

A: Focus on building a comprehensive skills portfolio:

1. Get industry-recognized certifications
2. Build a strong portfolio (GitHub, personal website, case studies)
3. Optimize your Indeed profile completely
4. Leverage AI tools like AIApply for resume optimization
5. Network actively and gather recommendations
6. Document any existing Indeed scores immediately

The Bottom Line: Your Skills Still Matter

Look, is Proficient good on Indeed? Absolutely—it's literally the best score you can get in their system. But here's the real talk: The game is changing, and fast.

The end of Indeed assessments isn't the apocalypse some make it out to be. It's an opportunity to differentiate yourself in more meaningful ways. While everyone else panics about losing their test scores, you can be building a portfolio that actually shows what you can do.

Remember These Key Truths:

✅ Proficient = Good (it's the highest score available)
✅ Document existing scores NOW (they're becoming extinct)
✅ Skills still matter (just proved differently)
✅ The job market is evolving (adapt or get left behind)
✅ Every advantage counts (when facing 250 competitors)

The Current Job Market Reality:

As of May 2025:

• Unemployment rate: 4.2% (relatively low historically)
• Job openings: ~7.6 million (still more jobs than unemployed workers)
• Average applications per job: 250 (competition is fierce)
• Applications needed to land a job: 100-200 (persistence required)

Ready to Take Your Job Search to the Next Level?

Whether you're proudly displaying Proficient scores or starting fresh in the post-assessment era, success comes from a comprehensive strategy—not just test scores.

In today's market, where the average job gets 250 applications and only 4-6 people get interviewed, you need every possible advantage.

AIApply's AI-Powered Suite Helps You:

🎯 Create ATS-Optimized Resumes

• Highlight your verified skills effectively
• Beat the 98% of resumes rejected by ATS systems
• Create multiple versions for different roles
• Update instantly as you gain new certifications

✉️ Generate Tailored Cover Letters

• Reference your proficiencies naturally
• Customize for each application in seconds
• Stand out from template users
• Tell your unique skills story

🚀 Auto-Apply to Hundreds of Jobs

• Target positions matching your skills
• Apply at scale without sacrificing quality
• Track what's working
• Save 10+ hours per week

🎤 Practice Interviews with AI

• Prepare to discuss your skills confidently
• Get real-time feedback
• Practice industry-specific questions
• Build confidence before the real thing

The job market is evolving. Make sure your application strategy evolves with it.

In a world where Indeed assessments are disappearing but competition is fiercer than ever, you need tools that give you an edge. Join thousands of job seekers who've already discovered the power of AI-assisted job searching.

Start Your Free Trial Today →

Because in the end, it's not just about whether Proficient is good on Indeed—it's about building a comprehensive strategy that gets you hired.

Last updated: May 2025. This guide reflects Indeed's October 2024 announcement to discontinue assessments and current best practices for job seekers navigating this major change.

Sources:

1. Indeed Support - Product Update: Indeed is Discontinuing Assessments
2. Glassdoor - 2024 Job Application Statistics
3. Resume.io - How Many Applications to Get a Job
4. U.S. Bank - Effect of Job Market on Economy (May 2025)
5. SHRM - March 2025 Labor Market Review
6. Indeed Hiring Lab - 2025 US Jobs & Hiring Trends Report
7. JobTestPrep - Indeed Assessments Practice Guide 2024
8. ConsumerAffairs - Job Search Statistics 2025